Exclusive:Mairi McAllan: ‘Milburn Review could have significant knock-on impacts for Scottish budget’

The Milburn Review will be published on Tuesday aimed at getting young people off benefits and into work

A major review aimed at tackling rising youth unemployment and welfare dependence could have “significant knock-on impacts” on Scotland’s budget, the education secretary has warned.

Mairi McAllan told The Scotsman any cuts to welfare spending would “not be acceptable”, adding that the implications of the Milburn Review, which is to be published on Tuesday, will be “carefully considered”.

As the social security system is partly devolved, choices made by the UK Labour government at Westminster may have consequences north of the Border.

Ahead of the review’s publication, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said a “complete reset” of the system is needed to help 16 to 24-year-olds “Neets” - not in education, work or training - the number of whom topped one million earlier this year.

Some young people will receive less financial support under the proposals put forward by former UK health secretary Alan Milburn.

This could include moving them off some health-related benefits such as Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and on to a new “youth allowance” paid at the standard rate of universal credit.

Asked whether he agreed that some people should lose the welfare they currently receive, Mr McFadden told the BBC’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg show: “There will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today.”

Amid concerns among some Labour backbenchers about the extent of future support, he urged MPs to view the changes as a “different proposition” to last year, when Sir Keir Starmer’s government was forced to abandon planned welfare cuts in the face of rebellion.

In Scotland, the devolved equivalent of PIP is Adult Disability Payment (ADP).

Ms McAllan said it is not currently clear what proposed changes would mean for Social Security Scotland’s budget but added that any moves will be “significant”.

She said: “Any changes to UK Government disability social security and spending on employment support will have significant knock-on impacts for Scotland’s people and our budget in future years.

“We would expect to be consulted on these matters so that implications for Scotland can be carefully considered.”

The education secretary said that any cuts to Barnet Consequential funding would be “not acceptable”. Scotland’s finance secretary Jenny Gilruth is due to unveil the Scottish budget next month.

Ms McAllan added: “Given the UK government has already cut Scotland’s budget for next year by £650 million in real terms, the idea that further cuts could come as a result of this review is not acceptable.

“We will consider the report and any implications for Scotland carefully.”

Mr Milburn’s review on Tuesday is expected to recommend radical changes to reduce welfare dependency.

The former Labour frontbencher, who was commissioned by Sir Keir to carry out the work, also said young people deserve a “legal guarantee” of a route into employment.

It is unclear whether this would be a UK-wide guarantee and what impact it would have on funding for Scotland.

Ms McAllan pointed out the Milburn Review does not cover Scotland and the preliminary report highlighted areas where Scotland is already taking a different approach.

“We are so ambitious for our young people however we know that they face unique challenges in today’s economy when, after nearly 20 years since the global financial crash, they have grown up through so many years of UK austerity and the economic and social catastrophe of Brexit,” she added.

The education secretary also pointed to figures for Scotland that show 93.6 per cent of 16 to 19 year olds are participating in education, training or employment, and 95.7 per cent of school leavers are in a positive destination three months after leaving school.

This marks the joint second highest on record and is higher than England.

However, last week the tertiary education minister, Alyn Smith, told The Scotsman’s sister title Scotland on Sunday he was not interested in “defending the status quo” and would work cross-party to “radicalise” the college sector to improve post-school options for young people.

Meanwhile, Andy Burnham promised “generational” reform with benefits as “the backstop, not the starting point” for young people ahead of the review.

The Prime Minister said government spending will shift away from “paying for failure” and towards “investing in success” with intervention throughout childhood to help those falling behind.

But he said this would come with “responsibilities”, writing in the Guardian: “If we give young people genuine opportunities to learn, train and work, we should expect them to take them where they can.

“Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point. The system will no longer begin by establishing which benefits a young person is entitled to receive.

“It will understand their ambitions and identify the help they need to achieve them.”

The Prime Minister has said the politically sensitive review will be a “watershed” moment but stopped short of promising to accept its recommendations in full.

He has also insisted paying for the reforms would not mean “more money” but “spending differently” in government when pressed on the large upfront investment they are expected to require.

“For too long, we have waited until young people reach adulthood and then tried to deal with the problems that have built up over the years. Under this Government, we will start much earlier, making sure children have the support they need at the moments that matter most,” he said.

He said the Government would respond to Mr Milburn’s review in “the coming weeks”, adding: “But I can say now that our response will not be in the manner of traditional Department for Work and Pensions reform.

“It will be societal and generational. We will rethink supporting childhood – shifting government spending from paying for failure to investing in success.”

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said the creation of legal entitlement “might sound a nice thing to do” but “doesn’t make sense”.

However, the Tory frontbencher tentatively backed other elements of Mr Milburn’s approach, saying his focus on moving away from “handing out cash for relatively mild conditions” and towards employment support was “the right direction of travel”.

“We think he should do it for all ages, not just under 25. You should not have a different system for a 24-year-old and a 26-year-old,” she told Sky.

Reform UK’s Danny Kruger similarly said he was “encouraged” by “the suggestion that we need to be much stricter about benefits for young people who should be supported into work or should be working”.

But he added that he did not expect Labour to accept this, telling the same programme: “There’ll be indications that they want to, but the fact is, as we saw with Keir Starmer’s rather weak attempt to make a couple of billion pounds of savings from the welfare bill last year, the backbenchers won’t take it.”

The MP added: “I expect Labour will end up taking the extra spending on support for young people, but they won’t do the cuts. What we actually need to do is to take a much more robust approach.”

Comments

 0 comments

Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.

Dare to be Honest
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice